The Welsh government is being urged to strip glass from its deposit return scheme before it repeats what the industry now openly refers to as Scotland's failed experiment. A coalition of trade bodies, led by the WSTA, has come out hard against the current structure of the Welsh DRS, warning it is on the "same disastrous path" as the Scottish scheme that launched in 2023 and has been mired in operational chaos, retailer burden, and logistical dysfunction ever since.
Scotland's DRS became a cautionary tale fast. Glass was a central point of contention from the start, with operators and producers alike flagging that the infrastructure simply wasn't there to handle returns at scale. The costs of collection, storage, and processing fell disproportionately on smaller venues and independent retailers, and the scheme's administrator, Circularity Scotland, collapsed entirely in 2024 after the Scottish Government was forced to delay and restructure. Wales, the WSTA argues, is drafting its own version without adequately absorbing those lessons.
The trade's position is consistent: glass should be excluded from DRS and handled through existing kerbside recycling infrastructure instead. The argument isn't anti-environmental, it's operational. Glass is heavy, breakable in transit, and requires a separate reverse logistics chain that most hospitality businesses aren't equipped to manage. Plastic and aluminium, by contrast, have demonstrated workable return models in other markets. Asking a busy pub or independent off-licence to become a de facto glass return depot adds cost and complexity with limited environmental upside when kerbside alternatives exist.
Wales hasn't launched its scheme yet, which is precisely why the industry is pressing now. There's still a window to course-correct, and the WSTA and its coalition partners are making clear they'll push hard to use it. Whether the Welsh Government is listening is another question, but the trade has Scotland as a ready-made argument, and it's a difficult one to dismiss.
Sources: